Rise, Darthbob Blackpants...
I was really tempted to do a craptastic on StarWars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith. There was one problem on it though: it wasn't crap. It's not the best movie I've seen, but it definitely isn't bad. George Lucas still can't direct, and Hayden Christensen still performed better in Shattered Glass. Heck, even Natalie Portman had a better performance in Episode II, and that says a lot considering how haphazard the acting in that movie was.
The acting was nothing special. The story was decent but nothing new. I guess it was the fact that this movie was a lot more action-oriented than the past ones, and the fact that it closed off a lot of plotholes in the trilogy also helped.
However, I think the reason I really liked it is that it has to be the most unintentionally silly movie I've seen. Well, Reign of Fire is the first, but this has to be a close second. The writing is laughable, and there are a lot of things that STILL defy logic. I'll be getting to those now:
(SPOILERS, OF COURSE)
1) Why is it called "Revenge of the Sith?" Why are they having their revenge? Better yet, what are they avenging? I don't get it. It could have been better titled "Return of the Sith" but apparently that would have made the title too similar to "Return of the Jedi." "Attack of the Sith" sounds too much like "Attack of the Clones." Maybe that's why they settled with "Revenge," even if it makes no sense.
2) How did the Emperor come up with the name "Darth Vader?" Why not "Darthbob Squarepants?" Or maybe "Darth Anarchis." I mean, why "Vader?" Maybe it's shorthand for "invader," the same way "Sidious" is shorthand for "insidious." But still, it makes no sense. Vader technically never invaded anyone, he stayed with the republic and helped the republic kill all the separatists. He never invaded anyone, he killed the invaders. Darth "Maul" made sense because he mauled everyone around him, but "Vader?" Man, I would have preferred Darthbob Blackpants myself. Oh well.
3) Similarly, how did Padme come up with the names Luke and Leia? It's as if they came out of thin air. At least in the novels chronicling the events after episode 6, they explained how Princess Leia and Han Solo came about naming their kids Jacen and Jaina: they talked it over. Episode 3 makes no such clarification. It's as if in her birthing bed she just thought the names up. There are so many other names out there, and she had to settle for those two. I don't get it.
4) This line wins the award for cheesiest line of this millenium: "Hello my little green friend." I don't know why, but hearing an insidious, scheming Sith lord say that to a green midget like Yoda just made me snicker. It feels like something more fit for a mafia movie.
5) Natalie Portman's acting has taken a turn for the worse. Her drama scenes were passable, but as the movie went along, her acting got worse. When Obi Wan demanded to know where Anakin was after he turned Sith, her acting felt very forced, those tears did not strike me as natural. Later on when she met her love again right before the big duel between him and Obi Wan her acting really went to the dumps. No offense meant, but I snickered when Anakin was choking the life out of her, not because I am sadistic but because she did not strike me as someone who was choking. If she was, she would not be able to speak so clearly. She looked like someone who was clutching her throat for the heck of it.
Anyway, I'll keep it at that, mainly because I want to update my other blog. So, I'll leave it at that.
